Skip to main content


Cali Lemon Lawyers Logo

We Get You Paid Nosotros te pagamos

Fast & Easy 🍋 Rápido y fácil 🍋

How does the Lemon Law Work?

How does the Lemon Law Work in California?

Wondering how does the lemon law work? No one should have to deal with the burden of buying or leasing a defective car. For that reason, the lemon law was created to protect consumers of the inevitable fact that some new and used cars are sold with unacceptable problems.

California’s Lemon Law, more formally known as the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act, holds manufacturers accountable for new and used vehicles with a substantial defect. This accountability is accomplished by requiring manufacturers to either replace or repurchase a vehicle that meets specific criteria.

California Lemon Law covers consumers by requiring refund or replacement car are appropriately protected thanks to its stringent consumer protection laws.

In this post, we’ll take a closer at the details of California’s Lemon Law, how Lemon Laws work nationwide and what you can do to preserve your rights.

Lemon Law: How Does it Work?

Lemon Law: How Does it Work?

The Lemon Law works to ensure protections for consumers who have purchased or leased a vehicle with issues that impact its use, value, or safety. For those that find themselves in this unfortunate circumstance, these laws allow you to seek compensation, a vehicle replacement, or a refund for your car.

Fun Fact: The term “lemon” has been used to describe a defective product since the early 20th century. The first Lemon Law was passed in Connecticut in 1982, and since then, all 50 states have enacted their versions of the Lemon Law.

Types of Lemon Laws

Federal Lemon Law: Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act The Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, passed in 1975, is a federal law that governs consumer product warranties, including vehicles. This act provides a framework for the Lemon Law and requires manufacturers to honor their warranties and address defects within a reasonable time.

State Lemon Laws: Variations and key differences Each state has its version of the Lemon Law, with specific criteria, remedies, and procedures. While the underlying principles are similar, it is crucial to understand the Lemon Law in your state to ensure you are adequately protected.

What Kind Of Vehicles Are Covered Under Lemon Laws

What Kind Of Vehicles Are Covered Under Lemon Laws

Most Lemon Laws apply to new cars and trucks sold or leased within a state.

Some states’ Lemon Laws cover motorcycles and recreational vehicles (RVs), though the extent of protection may vary. Research your state’s laws to confirm coverage for these types of vehicles.

In many states, leased vehicles are covered under the Lemon Law, affording lessees similar protections to those who purchase their vehicles outright.

How to Identify a Lemon Car

A “lemon” is best defined as a vehicle with significant defects that cannot be repaired after a reasonable number of attempts or within a specified period. Common signs of a lemon include persistent mechanical issues, faulty electrical systems, or defects covered under warranty that affect the vehicle’s safety.

Some typical defects in lemons include engine and transmission problems, brake and steering system failures, and issues with the air conditioning or heating systems. In some cases, these defects may be easily identifiable, while in others, they may only become apparent over time.

What Qualifies A Car As A Lemon?

What Qualifies A Car As A Lemon?

Number of repair attempts

To qualify under the Lemon Law, a vehicle must have had 2 or more unsuccessful repair attempts for under warranty. The required number of attempts may vary by state, but generally, it ranges between two and four.

Duration of repair

What if my dealership has been in the car for a month? Another criterion for Lemon Law eligibility is the length of time a vehicle spends in the repair shop. If a car is out of service for a specified number of days during the warranty period, it may qualify as a lemon.

Impact on vehicle’s use, value, or safety

Lastly, if the defect significantly impair the vehicle’s use, value, or safety it’s extremely likely to qualify for Lemon Law protection.

How to Pursue a Lemon Law Claim

How to Pursue a Lemon Law Claim

To build a strong case for your Lemon Law claim, keep detailed records of all repair attempts, communications with the dealer or manufacturer, and any expenses incurred due to the vehicle’s defects.

Most state Lemon Laws require consumers to notify the manufacturer of the defect in writing before pursuing a claim. This notice should include a description of the issue, the repair history, and a request for a remedy under the Lemon Law.

Depending on your state’s Lemon Law, you may be required to participate in arbitration or mediation before filing a lawsuit. In some cases, you may choose between these options and litigation to resolve your claim.

The Role of a Lemon Law Attorney

A Lemon Law attorney can help you navigate the complexities of the legal process, negotiate with the manufacturer on your behalf, and ensure that your rights are protected.

You’ll want to choose a lawyer with extensive experience in Lemon Law cases and a track record of success. Get recommendations from friends, read reviews, and interview potential attorneys to find the best fit for your case.

Many Lemon Law attorneys (including ours) work on a contingency basis, meaning they only collect fees if they successfully resolve your case. This arrangement can make pursuing a Lemon Law claim more accessible and less financially risky for consumers.

Lemon Law Buyback and Compensation Scenarios

Lemon Law Buyback and Compensation Scenarios

Buyback options

If your vehicle qualifies as a lemon, the manufacturer may be required to repurchase the vehicle, providing you with a refund or credit towards a new vehicle.

Cash compensation

In some cases, the manufacturer may offer cash compensation in lieu of a buyback, allowing you to keep the vehicle and receive financial compensation for the diminished value or inconvenience caused by the defects.

Vehicle replacement

Alternatively, the manufacturer may offer to replace the defective vehicle with a comparable new vehicle, effectively “trading” the lemon for a problem-free vehicle.

Lemon Law FAQs

How long do I have to file a claim?

The Lemon Law time limit to file a claim varies by state, but typically, you must file within a specific period following the purchase or lease of the vehicle or within a certain mileage range.

Can I return a used car under the Lemon Law?

Some states have provisions for used cars under their Lemon Laws, while others do not. Research your state’s laws and consult with an attorney to determine if your used vehicle is eligible for protection.

How much does it cost to pursue a Lemon Law claim?

Legal fees for pursuing a Lemon Law claim can vary, but our attorneys work on a contingency basis, meaning you only pay if your case is successful. Additionally, some states require the manufacturer to pay your legal fees if you win your case.

What if my state doesn’t have a Lemon Law?

All 50 states have Lemon Laws in place (some – like California – are more friendly than others), but coverage and criteria can vary. If your state’s Lemon Law does not apply to your situation, the federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act may provide an avenue for recourse.

How does the Lemon Law affect my warranty?

The Lemon Law works in conjunction with your warranty, ensuring that manufacturers honor their warranty commitments and address defects within a reasonable time frame.

Lemon Law Tips and Tricks

Want some tips for winning your lemon law case? Here’s what you need to know:

Keep detailed records

Maintaining thorough documentation of all repairs, communications, and expenses related to your vehicle’s defects is crucial to building a strong Lemon Law case.

Be persistent and assertive

Stand your ground when dealing with manufacturers and dealers, insisting on your rights under the Lemon Law. Persistence and assertiveness can lead to a more favorable outcome.

Stay informed and up-to-date on laws

Keep yourself informed about changes and updates to your state’s Lemon Law, as well as any relevant federal legislation. Staying current on the law can help you better understand and assert your rights.

Our Lemon Law Success Stories

Here at Cali Lemon Lawyers, we’ve reviewed over 40,000 cases and have a 99% across all pursued Lemon Law claims. These success stories serve as inspiration and validation for others facing similar challenges.

With our vast experience in the field, you can lean on us for valuable insights into best practices, strategies, and tips for navigating the legal process and achieving a favorable outcome.

Final Thoughts on How The Lemon Law Works

The Lemon Law is a critical piece of consumer protection legislation, ensuring that consumers are not left to bear the financial burden of defective vehicles. By understanding and asserting your rights under the Lemon Law, you can help promote greater accountability and responsibility among manufacturers and dealers.

Being informed about the Lemon Law, its criteria, and the legal process empowers you to take action if you find yourself with a lemon. By pursuing your rights and seeking appropriate remedies, you can help make the automotive market safer and more reliable for all consumers.

Skip to content